AI Boom Will Produce Victors and Carnage, Tech Boss Warns

LONDON – The global race to harness the power of Artificial Intelligence will create immense wealth and revolutionary applications, but it will also leave a trail of corporate "carnage" reminiscent of the dotcom bust, a leading technology executive has warned. Chuck Robbins, the chairman and chief executive of Cisco Systems, cautioned that while AI's impact will be "bigger than the internet," the current frenzy of investment carries the hallmarks of a speculative bubble that will bankrupt some companies and vaporise capital.

In an interview with the BBC, the head of the $200 billion networking giant provided a sober forecast from the heart of the AI boom. Cisco, a critical supplier of the infrastructure that powers AI, is fielding unprecedented demand. Yet, having navigated the collapse of the dotcom bubble in 2000, Robbins is sounding an alarm for investors and businesses caught up in the hype.

His comments echo a growing chorus of concern from the highest levels of finance and technology, where leaders are grappling with the immense promise and palpable risk of the current AI gold rush.

---

An Echo of the Dotcom Era

The parallels to the late 1990s are becoming too stark for industry veterans to ignore. Sceptics point to soaring valuations and a flood of capital into any company with "AI" in its pitch deck as evidence of a market detached from fundamentals.

This sentiment is shared by other influential figures:

• Wall Street's Warning: JPMorgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon recently stated that while AI is real, some of the vast sums being invested would "probably be lost," acknowledging the speculative nature of the boom.
• Silicon Valley's Caution: Sundar Pichai, chief executive of Google's parent company Alphabet, conceded there was some "irrationality" in the market, even as his own company invests billions in the technology.

Cisco itself serves as a powerful case study. In March 2000, at the peak of the dotcom mania, it was the most valuable company in the world. When the bubble burst, its market value plummeted by over 80%. The company survived and rebuilt, a testament to the fact that underlying technological shifts can be real even when market valuations are not.

"There's been a lot of discussion about: 'Is this a bubble?'. And the answer is probably yes," Robbins stated. "But we had a bubble in 2000 with the internet. And look at where we are today."

The Anatomy of a Tech Bubble

Robbins' warning distinguishes between the technology itself and the market's reaction to it. He argues that even if the current market is a bubble, the long-term impact of AI remains undeniable.

• The Carnage: "You'll have money that will be invested in companies that won't make it," Robbins explained. This phase will see failed startups, missed earnings, and significant losses for less discerning investors.
• The Victors: "The winners will emerge, and there's carnage along the way," he added. Just as giants like Amazon and Google rose from the dotcom ashes, a new class of dominant, world-changing companies will be forged in the AI boom.
• The Evolution: Robbins compared the current stage of AI to the early days of the iPhone, where the most transformative applications were yet to be invented. "The applications and use cases will begin to evolve," he said, suggesting the true potential of AI will unfold over many years.

Cisco's View from the Engine Room

Cisco's perspective is uniquely valuable. The company provides the essential networking hardware and infrastructure—the digital plumbing—that connects the powerful AI-focused processors from firms like Nvidia, which have seen their valuations skyrocket.

Cisco is a direct beneficiary of the boom, with Robbins noting the company has £1.3 billion in AI-related orders in the current quarter alone. This position, as a supplier of the "picks and shovels" in the gold rush, gives it a clear view of the scale of investment and the key players involved. Its strategic partnership with Nvidia places it at the epicentre of the hardware build-out required to train and run complex AI models.

Despite this lucrative position, Robbins' experience with the 2000 crash informs his cautious outlook. "It feels a lot like it," he said, referring to the dotcom collapse.

The Impact on the Workforce

Beyond financial markets, the most pressing concern for many is the impact of AI on jobs. Robbins addressed this directly, advising workers to adapt rather than resist.

He confirmed that some jobs, particularly in areas like customer service, will be changed or "eliminated" as companies find they need "fewer people" to perform certain tasks. However, he reframed the threat.

"You shouldn't worry as much about AI taking your job as you should worry about someone who's very good using AI taking your job," Robbins advised. The key to remaining relevant, he argued, is to embrace the technology and learn how to leverage it as a tool for productivity and innovation.

Security: The Double-Edged Sword

With great technological power comes significant risk. Robbins highlighted the inevitable security challenges that will accompany the proliferation of AI.

• The Threat Amplified: "It's going to make our cyber attacks better. It's going to make the scams that people see in their inboxes seem more real," he warned. The ability of AI to generate convincing text, images, and code will be exploited by malicious actors.
• The Industry's Response: Robbins expressed confidence in the tech industry's ability to counter these threats. "Every time we've had a big technological revolution, there's always a security risk associated with it," he said. He noted that Cisco is already deploying advanced tools, including quantum technology, to build more robust security protocols to mitigate AI-driven risks.

The Geopolitical Dimension

The race for AI supremacy is currently dominated by the United States and China. However, Robbins suggested the field is still open enough for other nations to become major players. He gave the United Kingdom "pretty good odds" of becoming an AI superpower.

"It's early enough right now, and I think the one thing we know is that the countries who embrace AI are going to be the countries that win," he said. "I think that the UK has always been forward-leaning on these technology transitions."

This presents a critical imperative for governments worldwide. Proactive investment, supportive regulation, and fostering a skilled workforce will be the deciding factors in which nations thrive in the coming AI-driven economy. For investors, workers, and policymakers, the message is clear: the AI revolution is here, but navigating it will require a steady hand, a healthy dose of scepticism, and the resilience to survive the inevitable carnage on the path to victory.