Six Nations 2026: Scotland drop Van der Merwe, Graham & Kinghorn

ROME – In a strategic pivot that has sent shockwaves through international rugby, Scotland Head Coach Gregor Townsend has executed one of the most audacious selection gambles of his tenure, omitting three of his highest-value backline assets for the 2026 Guinness Six Nations opener against Italy. Duhan van der Merwe and Darcy Graham, the nation's top two all-time try-scorers, along with British and Irish Lions Test full-back Blair Kinghorn, have been left out of the starting XV in a move that signals a profound shift in team strategy and a high-stakes investment in squad depth.

The decision represents a calculated risk, removing a combined total of 66 international tries from the starting lineup. Townsend is betting on a new-look, club-forged combination to deliver a crucial opening-round victory in Rome, a fixture that has become increasingly challenging for visiting teams. The market has reacted with a mixture of surprise and intrigue, as analysts weigh the short-term risk against the potential long-term rewards of blooding new talent.

---

The New-Look Asset Portfolio

Townsend has liquidated his established back-three holdings in favor of a new portfolio heavily weighted towards Glasgow Warriors' recent form. The selection prioritizes club-level synergy and rewards domestic performance over established international reputation.

• The New Full-Back: Tom Jordan of Bristol Bears is the surprise choice at number 15. Known more as a fly-half, his selection at full-back is a clear indicator of Townsend's desire for a secondary playmaker to support Finn Russell, enhancing Scotland's attacking optionality.

• The Wing Investment: The flanks will be patrolled by an all-Glasgow duo. Kyle Steyn, a reliable and powerful finisher, provides a degree of experience. He is joined by Jamie Dobie, who will make his first Six Nations start in a remarkable positional switch.

• The Dobie Experiment: Dobie, a career scrum-half, has been a revelation on the wing for Glasgow this season. His inclusion is Townsend's boldest move, a direct investment in raw pace and attacking instinct. This selection will be scrutinized as a key performance indicator of the coach's talent identification and development strategy.

While Graham is named among the replacements, providing experienced cover, the complete exclusion of Van der Merwe and Kinghorn from the matchday 23 is the most significant data point. It sends an unequivocal message that no position is guaranteed and that performance in the national camp is the ultimate currency.

Backline Reserves and Stability

The bench composition further underscores this new philosophy.

• Backs Cover: Adam Hastings and George Horne provide cover for the fly-half and scrum-half positions, respectively. Horne's inclusion over a dedicated back-three player suggests a strategy reliant on versatility and a high-tempo finish.
• The Established Core: Amidst the upheaval, the core of the backline remains a blue-chip asset. The partnership of Ben White and vice-captain Finn Russell at half-back continues, despite the strong form of Horne. The midfield is the trusted and formidable pairing of Huw Jones and captain Sione Tuipulotu, who will mark their 18th Test match together, providing a crucial pillar of stability.

---

Forward Pack: A Foundation of Continuity

In stark contrast to the backline revolution, the forward pack selected by Townsend is built on a foundation of experience and continuity, with a heavy contingent from the in-form Glasgow Warriors. Nine of the starting XV and a further five on the bench hail from the Scottish club, creating a powerful unit with built-in cohesion.

The Front and Second Row

• Front Row Power: The formidable British and Irish Lions props Pierre Schoeman and Zander Fagerson will anchor the scrum. They are joined by Ewan Ashman, Scotland's leading try-scoring forward, who gets the nod at hooker over the more experienced George Turner.

• Second Row Experience: In the engine room, veteran Grant Gilchrist, 35, has retained his starting position. His experience was deemed more valuable than the youthful energy of Gregor Brown and Max Williamson. He partners with Scott Cummings, whose return from an injury that sidelined him for last year's championship is a significant boost to Scotland's set-piece and lineout capability.

The All-Glasgow Back Row

The breakaway unit is a testament to the success of Glasgow's system, comprised entirely of Warriors players.

• Key Personnel: Matt Fagerson, vice-captain Rory Darge, and the powerful Jack Dempsey will form the trio. Their shared understanding and high work-rate will be critical in securing possession and disrupting Italy's attack.
• Versatile Cover: The versatile Gregor Brown provides cover for both the second and back rows from the bench, offering Townsend tactical flexibility as the game progresses.

---

Implications and The Road Ahead

Townsend's selection for this opening fixture is a declaration of intent for the entire 2026 championship and the cycle leading to the 2027 Rugby World Cup.

1. Managing High-Value Assets: The decision to rest or drop players of the calibre of Van der Merwe, Graham, and Kinghorn is a bold piece of portfolio management. It signals a move away from over-reliance on a few key individuals towards building a broader, more resilient asset base. The risk is an immediate hit to performance; the reward is greater depth and competition for places.

2. A Message of Meritocracy: The promotion of in-form players like Dobie and the retention of stalwarts like Gilchrist send a clear message: reputation alone is not enough. Performance, form, and fit within the specific game plan are the primary drivers of selection. This fosters a highly competitive internal environment.

3. The Italian Test: Saturday's match in Rome is no longer a simple accounting exercise for a bonus-point win. It is now the first major test of Townsend's new strategic direction. A convincing victory will vindicate his choices and build momentum. A loss, or even a lackluster win, will invite intense scrutiny and pressure ahead of tougher fixtures.

All eyes will be on the Stadio Olimpico to see if this high-risk, high-reward strategy pays immediate dividends. The outcome will set the narrative for Scotland’s Six Nations campaign and offer a telling glimpse into Gregor Townsend’s blueprint for the future.