West Midlands Railway joins publicly owned Great British Railways

By a Senior Financial Correspondent, BBC Business

West Midlands Railway (WMR) is being brought under direct public control, marking the latest and one of the most significant moves in the government's sweeping overhaul of the nation's rail network. The operator, which has been plagued by years of underperformance, will be stripped from its private operator and integrated into the emerging state-run body, Great British Railways (GBR).

The decision, announced today by the Department for Transport (DfT), follows intense pressure from passengers and politicians over the operator's consistent failure to provide a reliable service. This move signals a definitive shift away from the fragmented rail franchise model that has defined Britain's railways for nearly three decades.

In a candid statement explaining the intervention, a government spokesperson highlighted the core issue driving the decision, noting it was "because we know that for years people have had to put up with delays, cancellations, the frustration of standing on a platform on a Sunday and the train just never arriving".

This nationalisation effectively ends the management contract held by a consortium led by Abellio, the Dutch state-owned transport company. The services will now be run by the government's Operator of Last Resort (OLR), a body designed to take over failing franchises, which will operate the service under the GBR brand.

---

A Legacy of Underperformance

The government's intervention was not a sudden decision but the culmination of a long period of service decline that eroded passenger trust and damaged the regional economy. The operator's performance metrics have consistently fallen short of contractual obligations and passenger expectations.

The specific failures cited by the DfT and passenger groups paint a stark picture of a service in crisis.

• Punctuality and Cancellations: WMR has been one of the worst-performing operators in the UK for punctuality. In the last reporting year, its Public Performance Measure (PPM) frequently dipped below acceptable levels, with some routes experiencing on-time arrivals of less than 70%. Cancellation rates, particularly on weekends and during periods of staff shortage, have been a major source of public anger.

• Passenger Dissatisfaction: Independent surveys from transport watchdogs like Transport Focus have consistently ranked WMR near the bottom for overall passenger satisfaction. Complaints have centred on overcrowding, the poor quality of rolling stock, and a lack of timely and accurate information during disruptions.

• Failure to Deliver on Investment: While some new trains were introduced, key commitments in the franchise agreement regarding station upgrades, timetable enhancements, and service frequency improvements were either significantly delayed or never fully realised, leading to accusations that the operator was failing to reinvest adequately in the network.

• Economic Impact: The unreliability of the service has had a tangible negative impact on the West Midlands economy. Commuters have faced lost productivity, and businesses have cited poor transport links as a barrier to growth and employee retention in the region.

---

The Great British Railways Context

This move cannot be viewed in isolation. It is a central plank of the government's ambitious plan to reform the railways, as outlined in the Williams-Shapps Plan for Rail. The creation of Great British Railways aims to end the fragmentation of the post-privatisation era.

The core objective of GBR is to act as a single "guiding mind" for the entire network.

Key Goals of GBR:

• Integrated System: GBR will be responsible for both track and train, contracting with private companies to run the trains to its specifications, similar to the model used by Transport for London. This is intended to eliminate the blame-shifting between track operator Network Rail and the train operating companies.

• Simplified Fares and Ticketing: A key promise is the rollout of a simplified, nationally coordinated fare structure, including flexible season tickets and pay-as-you-go options across the country, making travel easier and more affordable.

• Passenger-First Duty: GBR will have a statutory duty to prioritise the interests of passengers, a significant shift from the previous franchise model, which was often criticised for putting shareholder profits first.

The absorption of WMR into this structure is a practical application of this new philosophy. It follows the earlier nationalisation of services on the East Coast Main Line (now LNER) and Northern Rail, both of which were also taken over by the OLR after private-sector failures.

---

Financial and Industry Implications

The transfer of WMR to public ownership carries significant financial consequences for the taxpayer, the former operator, and the wider rail industry.

• Operator Liabilities: The government, via the OLR, will now assume all operational costs and revenue risks associated with the West Midlands network. While this exposes the taxpayer to potential losses, it also means any future operating surpluses can be directly reinvested into the service rather than being paid out as dividends.

• Signal to the Market: This decision sends a powerful message to the remaining private operators. The government has demonstrated it will not hesitate to terminate contracts for persistent underperformance. This is expected to increase pressure on other struggling operators to improve their services or face a similar fate.

• End of the Franchise Era: For the rail industry, this is another definitive nail in the coffin of the old franchising system. The new GBR model will be based on "Passenger Service Contracts," where private firms are paid a fee to run services to a tight specification set by GBR, which retains the revenue and cost risk. This lower-risk model is expected to attract a different type of private partner, focused on operational excellence rather than revenue forecasting.

---

The Path Forward

The immediate priority for the Operator of Last Resort will be to stabilise the service and restore a basic level of reliability for West Midlands passengers. This will involve a detailed review of operations, management, and staffing.

In the short term, passengers should expect:

• A focus on improving driver training and availability to reduce cancellations.
• A renewed effort to improve the reliability of the existing fleet.
• More transparent communication during periods of disruption.

Longer-term goals include:

• Fully integrating the West Midlands network into the GBR national brand and ticketing systems.
• Developing a long-term investment plan for new trains and infrastructure upgrades in coordination with regional bodies like West Midlands for Transport (WfT).
• Rebuilding passenger trust and encouraging a return to rail travel post-pandemic.

While the transition to public control offers the promise of a more accountable and passenger-focused railway, the OLR faces a monumental task. Years of underinvestment and operational challenges cannot be fixed overnight. The success of this move will ultimately be judged not by the change in ownership, but by whether the trains, at last, start running on time.